• corsicanguppy@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    13 hours ago

    Pay attention in school, kids, lest you miss learning what a binary choice is.

    And evolution.

    • IttihadChe@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      5
      ·
      11 hours ago

      “Pay attention in school, kids, lest you miss learning what a king is”

      ~ defender of kings prior to their overthrow.

      “Pay attention in school kids, lest you miss learning what an autocratic dictatorship is”

      ~ Cuban Batista defenders prior to the revolution.

      “Pay attention in school slaves, lest you miss learning what a slave master is”

      ~ Southern slaveholder prior to the abolition of slavery.

      Yes, when you confine your thinking to only exist within the current system, thats all you can comprehend.

      Here’s the thing though, when the choice is between two slides towards fascism, A steep one, and a slightly less but still increasingly steep as you descend one, the only way to escape fascism is not to choose which slide you take, but to build an off ramp.

      You will not defeat the system from working within, you need to build external power structures.

      • agamemnonymous@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        3
        ·
        edit-2
        10 hours ago

        Pay attention in school, kids, lest you miss learning what a king is"

        ~ defender of kings prior to their overthrow.

        “Pay attention in school kids, lest you miss learning what an autocratic dictatorship is”

        ~ Cuban Batista defenders prior to the revolution.

        “Pay attention in school slaves, lest you miss learning what a slave master is”

        ~ Southern slaveholder prior to the abolition of slavery.

        I don’t get your point, those are all very good things to know.

        You will not defeat the system from working within, you need to build external power structures.

        What does that look like in your mind? And how does that conflict with slowing the slide in the meantime while you build the off ramp?

        • IttihadChe@lemmy.ml
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          3
          ·
          edit-2
          9 hours ago
          1. They are all very good ways of framing the current system as the only system, one which you must just accept.

          2. I literally painted an outline above of what it looks like, not just in my mind but in reality. The Muslim/leftist community drew a line on the Gaza genocide, and the Democrats crossed it. The Muslim/leftist community then worked together to make it known that the Democrats were now our enemy for crossing said line.

          The Democrats can either cross back, or they can continue their fascist march, while you defend them.

          You must exit the slide because if you don’t you will inevitably find yourself supporting fascism, just like how the democratic party defenders are defending Genocide, something I’m sure you all thought would be a solid line only a few years ago. But you crossed it, and will continue to cross any other lines until we reach full implemented fascism, at which point you will wonder why “nobody resisted”…

          • agamemnonymous@sh.itjust.works
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            1
            arrow-down
            3
            ·
            8 hours ago
            1. They are all very good ways of framing the current system as the only system, one which you must just accept.

            They’re all also very good ways of understanding the system. How do you fight an autocratic dictatorship if you don’t know what that is?

            1. I literally painted an outline above of what it looks like, not just in my mind but in reality. The Muslim/leftist community drew a line on the Gaza genocide, and the Democrats crossed it. The Muslim/leftist community then worked together to make it known that the Democrats were now our enemy for crossing said line

            I saw. Consequently, the fast fascists won and made the Gaza genocide worse. I’m not sure how you can frame that as a positive result for Gaza.

            The Democrats can either cross back, or they can continue their fascist march, while you defend them.

            I’m not defending them, I’m advocating the leaser evil while not-evil is still too disorganized to gain power. It’s not enough for Democrats to lose, because the alternative is worse. If there is no alternative positioned to win, Democrats are still better than Republicans.

            You must exit the slide because if you don’t you will inevitably find yourself supporting fascism, just like how the democratic party defenders are defending Genocide, something I’m sure you all thought would be a solid line only a few years ago. But you crossed it, and will continue to cross any other lines until we reach full implemented fascism, at which point you will wonder why “nobody resisted”…

            Too late, we’re there. Neo-liberals weren’t pure enough, so now we have brown shirts and concentration camps. You haven’t actually outlined the alternative, all you’re doing is saying that lesser evil isn’t good enough. There is no good option with prospects to succeed, so refusing to support lesser evil just ensures a victory by the greater evil. And here we are.

            It’s not enough to oppose both evils. You need to have a good to replace them. If your good has no chance, you just empower the greater evil. Where is your good alternative with the power to win?